Rate my teams

[EasyMoney]

First one is a 12 teamer. 2nd pick. with half a point per reception. 20 rounds

QB's
Carson Palmer (4th)
Trent Edwards (20th)

RB's
A.P. (1nd)
MJD (2nd)
Johnathan Stewart (6th)
Chris Perry (9)
R. Mendenhall (10)
Kevin Jones (12)
Maurice Morris (14)
Pierre Thomas (18)

WR's
Andre Johnson (3)
Calvin Johnson (5)
Greg Jennings (7)
Anthony Gonzolez (8)
Vincent Jackson (13)
Mark Clayton (16)


TE
Owen Daniels (11)
Zach Miller (17)

K
Jason Hanson (19)

Def
Balt (15)

Second team is an 8 team league. I picked 8th

QB's
McNabb (9)
Bulger (13)

RB's
Frank Gore (1)
Jamal Lewis (3)
Thomas Jones (5)
Michael Turner (6)
Chris Perry (11)
Maurice Morris (15)
Kevin Jones (18)
Steve Slaton (19)

WR's
Randy Moss (2)
Andre Johnson (4)
Marvin Harrison (7)
Jerricho Cotchery (8)
Jerry Porter (12)
Vincent Jackson (17)

TE's
Jeremy Shockey (10)
Owen Daniels (14)

K
Josh Scobee (20)

Def
New England (16)

 

[JakeT.]

1st team:

QB: C-

Palmer is okay. Not sold on Edwards having much fantasy value.

RB: B+

AP is good. Jones-Drew is a good #2 in a 12-teamer. Lots of depth. I like it.

WR: B+

Good group. Three excellent guys with lots of potential. Gonzo as a 4th guy looks great.

TE: Too hung over to add anything interesting here.

Overall: B

Very nice team for a 12-teamer. Actually one of the best I've seen lately. I'm guessing you win this league.

2nd team:

QB: D

Not a great QB crew for an 8-teamer. Not high at all on Bulger.

RB: C+

You have four good running backs. Not a bad unit. Average.

WR: C

Moss is good but Harrison is older and Andre likes to get dinged. Injuries could hurt you badly here.

TE: Hangover.

Overall: C

It's a team that can be competitive but I just don't see enough talent for an 8-team league. I think you finish in the middle of the pack unless you can completely avoid the injury bug.